4 Differences Between Grammar and Independent Schools' 11 Plus

4 Differences Between Grammar and Independent Schools’ 11 Plus

The 11 Plus examination, a crucial assessment for students aiming to enter secondary education in the United Kingdom, varies significantly between grammar schools and independent schools.

Both types of institutions utilise this exam to gauge the aptitude and academic readiness of students, but the format, content, and objectives of the exams differ in notable ways.

For parents and students navigating this complex landscape, understanding these differences is essential for adequate preparation and informed decision-making.

Historical Context and Purpose

4 Differences Between Grammar and Independent Schools' 11 Plus

Grammar schools, a staple of the UK’s state education system, traditionally use the 11 Plus exam to select academically gifted students for entry into selective state-funded secondary schools.

The goal of these exams is to identify pupils with the potential to excel in an academically rigorous environment, ensuring that students are placed in a setting that matches their intellectual capabilities. This selection process has its roots in the post-war period, aimed at providing a meritocratic pathway for education.

Independent schools, on the other hand, are private institutions that operate outside the state school system. While they often use a version of the 11 Plus exam, their primary objective is to assess whether a student is a good fit for the unique ethos and academic standards of the school.

These schools seek to maintain a certain calibre of student body that aligns with their educational philosophy and values, and thus their entrance exams might place a different emphasis compared to grammar schools.

Exam Structure and Content

The structure and content of the 11 Plus exams for grammar schools typically include four main components: verbal reasoning, non-verbal reasoning, mathematics, and English.

Verbal reasoning tests linguistic skills and logical reasoning abilities through word problems and sequences. Non-verbal reasoning assesses a child’s ability to understand and analyse visual information and solve problems using pictures and patterns.

Mathematics covers a range of topics taught in primary school, such as arithmetic, algebra, and geometry, testing both straightforward calculations and problem-solving skills. English tests encompass reading comprehension, grammar, punctuation, and creative writing, reflecting a comprehensive evaluation of a student’s literacy skills.

Independent schools, however, often customise their 11 Plus exams to reflect their specific educational priorities. While they may also include verbal and non-verbal reasoning, mathematics, and English, the content can be more varied and tailored to the school’s curriculum.

For instance, some independent schools might place a greater emphasis on creative writing or critical thinking skills. Additionally, these exams can sometimes include subjects not commonly found in grammar school assessments, such as general knowledge or a second language, reflecting the broader academic focus of many independent schools.

Master the 11 Plus

A unique, confidence-boosting way to study for the 11 Plus

Differences in Administration and Format

4 Differences Between Grammar and Independent Schools' 11 Plus

The administration and format of the 11 Plus exams also differ between grammar and independent schools. Grammar school exams are generally administered by local education authorities or specific exam boards, such as GL Assessment or CEM (Centre for Evaluation and Monitoring).

These exams are usually standardised across regions, ensuring consistency in the assessment process. Students often sit these exams in their final year of primary school, typically around September.

Independent schools, however, have more autonomy in how they administer their entrance exams. Each school sets its own exam dates, which can vary widely, although they typically occur in January.

The format can also be more flexible, with some schools opting for multiple assessment days or including interviews and additional activities as part of the selection process. This flexibility allows independent schools to gain a holistic view of a student’s capabilities and fit within the school’s environment.

Preparation and Resources

Preparation for the 11 Plus exams for grammar schools is often more regimented, given the standardised nature of the tests. Numerous resources, including practice papers, online courses, and tutoring services, are tailored specifically to the format and content of these exams.

Parents and students can access a wealth of information and support to help navigate the preparation process, focusing on the specific skills and knowledge areas that will be tested.

For independent schools, preparation can be more challenging due to the bespoke nature of their exams. While general preparation in core subjects like mathematics and English remains beneficial, students might also need to prepare for unique elements of the exams, such as interviews or specific subject tests.

Resources for these exams tend to be more varied and less standardised, requiring a more tailored approach to preparation.


The 11 Plus exams for grammar schools and independent schools serve similar overarching purposes of student selection, yet they differ in many critical aspects. From historical contexts and exam structures to administration and preparation, understanding these differences is vital for parents and students.

By recognising the distinct objectives and formats of these 11 Plus exams, families can better prepare and make informed decisions, ultimately ensuring that students find the educational environment that best suits their needs and aspirations.